Which Is Better a Traditional IRA or a Roth?

POSTED ON: July 23, 2021

Traditional IRAs have been available to retirement savers who have earned income since 1974. That’s 23 years longer than Roth IRAs (introduced in 1997) have been on the scene. The big difference between these two types of individual retirement savings vehicles is when you pay federal (and possibly state) income tax on your savings.

Which Is Better a Traditional IRA or a Roth?

FedWeek’s recent article entitled “Does a Roth IRA, or Roth Conversion Make Sense for You?” explains that with a traditional IRA, if your income is below certain levels, you make pre-tax contributions to your IRA (that you may be able to deduct) and pay your taxes when you withdraw that money after retirement, when you may be in a lower tax bracket. You’re paying those taxes on both your contributions and the earnings on those contributions. In contrast, with a Roth IRA, you contribute already taxed money to the IRA and, if your withdrawals are qualified, you pay no taxes at the time of withdrawal.

If you started your retirement savings before the introduction of the Roth or if you have had incomes too high to allow you to contribute to a Roth, you may want to move more of your retirement savings from traditional IRAs (where you pay taxes at withdrawal) to Roth IRAs (where you pay taxes up front, but benefit from tax free growth).

A Roth IRA conversion allows you to move monies from your traditional IRA into a new or existing Roth IRA. There are no income limits or limits on the amount that can be converted, but you must pay tax on all untaxed monies that you convert. Therefore, if you converted money from a traditional IRA where you were able to deduct your contributions, you’d pay tax on every dollar you converted. And if you converted money from a traditional IRA where you were not able to deduct your contributions, you’d pay tax on the amount of the conversion that was attributable to earnings. These taxes would be at your rate for ordinary income. Think about these items, before you decide to convert money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA:

When will you need the money? If you have an immediate need for the funds or need them to support your current standard of living, then a Roth IRA conversion is probably not a good idea. But if you have no immediate need for the funds, a Roth IRA conversion can be a terrific way for your money to grow tax-free over your lifetime.

Where will the money come from to pay the tax? Typically, the money to pay the tax on the Roth IRA conversion should come from outside funds and not from a retirement account, if the conversion is to make sense. When a conversion is made, it almost always triggers a taxable event. As a result, your ability to pay that tax with outside money will go a long way in determining if a Roth IRA conversion is right for you.

What do you think future tax rates will be? If you think that your income tax rate will be the same or higher in retirement, then converting funds to a Roth IRA is wise. That’s because you’ll be paying your taxes at a lower rate. But if you believe your income tax rate will be lower in retirement, conversion, and keeping your traditional IRA, may not be right for you.

Often, it is best to have a “portfolo” of traditional IRAs and a “portfolio” of ROTH IRAs.  Why?  Because if you play your cards right, you can avoid the IRA being taxed when contributed, and also avoid the IRA being taxed when withdrawn.  How do you do this?  Let me explain it this way: if all you have are ROTH IRAs, you would not be able to “fill up” the lower tax brackets when you are retired.  The lower, or even zero tax bracket, could be filled up with distributions from your traditional IRA (which would be “taxable”, but taking up space in the zero tax bracket category), resulting in zero (or near zero) income taxes, and the remainder of your retirement income needs could be from a ROTH IRA which is not taxable upon distribution by defalt.  So having certain amounts in both Traditional and ROTH IRAs are a savvy way to maximially avoid taxes when they are earned during your earnings years AND avoid taxes in retirement.  It’s the definition of having your cake and eating it too!

If you would like to discuss your estate plan and how your IRAs fit into it, BOOK A CALL with Ted Vicknair today.

Reference: FedWeek (March 30, 2021) “Does a Roth IRA, or Roth Conversion Make Sense for You?”

Success Stories